When to Replace a Storage Bench

A storage bench is a very useful piece of furniture. It gives you a place to sit and a place to store things. Many people have one at home. It can be in the entryway, bedroom, living room, or even the laundry room.

Jul 11, 2025 - 18:26
 1
When to Replace a Storage Bench

A storage bench is a very useful piece of furniture. It gives you a place to sit and a place to store things. Many people have one at home. It can be in the entryway, bedroom, living room, or even the laundry room.

Like all furniture, a storage bench does not last forever. Over time, it can get old, worn out, or broken. Sometimes, it no longer fits your needs. At these times, you may think about replacing it.

But how do you know when to replace a storage bench? This article will help you understand the signs that show it’s time to get a new one.


1. The Bench Is Broken

The most obvious reason to replace a storage bench is when it is broken. This can mean many things:

  • The legs are loose or broken.

  • The seat is cracked or falling apart.

  • The lid won’t open or close properly.

  • The storage space inside is damaged.

If your bench is not safe to sit on, you should replace it. A broken bench can cause injuries.

If the damage is small, you might be able to fix it. But if the damage is large or keeps coming back, replacement is better.


2. It No Longer Supports Your Weight

Over time, the wood or materials of the bench can weaken. It may start to feel wobbly or soft. Sometimes, the bench sags in the middle.

If your bench feels unstable or unsafe to sit on, it is time to replace it. Sitting on a weak bench can cause accidents.

Make sure your bench can hold the weight it should. If it can’t, don’t wait to replace it.


3. The Storage Space Is Too Small

Your needs may change over time. You may have more things to store now than before.

If your storage bench is too small for your current needs, it may be time to replace it. A larger bench with more storage space will help keep your home organized.

Think about what you want to store. If your bench is full or overflowing, look for a bigger one.


4. It Does Not Fit Your Room Anymore

Sometimes your room changes. You may redecorate or move to a new home. The old bench may not match your new style.

If the bench looks out of place or is too big or too small for your room, consider replacing it. A bench that fits well adds beauty and comfort to your space.

A new bench can make your room feel fresh and inviting.


5. The Upholstery Is Worn Out

If your storage bench has fabric or cushions, these parts may wear out first.

Fabric can get stained, torn, or faded. Cushions can lose their softness and become uncomfortable.

If the upholstery looks bad or feels uncomfortable, think about replacing the bench. Sometimes you can replace just the cushion or fabric. But if the frame is old too, a new bench is better.


6. It Smells Bad

A storage bench can absorb odors over time. This is especially true if it is in a humid place or near pets.

If your bench smells musty, smoky, or otherwise bad, and cleaning does not help, it may be time to replace it.

Bad smells can be hard to remove from fabric and padding. A new bench will feel fresh and clean.


7. The Storage Mechanism Is Broken

Storage benches usually have a lid that opens or drawers that slide out. Sometimes these parts stop working well.

If the lid does not open smoothly, or the drawers get stuck, it can be very frustrating.

Sometimes you can fix these problems by oiling hinges or tracks. But if the problem is serious, replacing the bench might be easier.


8. It Is Difficult to Clean

If your bench is very old, the materials may become hard to clean. Fabric can become rough or stained beyond repair.

If cleaning takes a long time or does not work, consider a new bench with easier-to-clean materials. For example, benches with leather or vinyl covers are easier to wipe down.


9. You Want New Features

Sometimes, you want your bench to do more. Maybe you want a bench with more storage, or one that matches new furniture.

If your current bench cannot be upgraded or changed, replacing it is the way to go.

Modern benches may have better designs, softer cushions, or more compartments.


10. It Causes Allergies

Old upholstered benches can collect dust, pet hair, and mold. This can cause allergies or breathing problems.

If you or your family have allergy symptoms that worsen near the bench, try cleaning it well first.

If the problem remains, replace the bench with one made of allergy-friendly materials.


11. The Bench Is Too Heavy or Bulky

Some storage benches are very heavy or large. If you move often or need to rearrange your room, this can be a problem.

If your bench is hard to move or does not fit through doors easily, consider replacing it with a lighter or smaller one.

This makes your life easier and gives you more flexibility in your space.


12. The Style Is Outdated

Styles change over time. What looked nice years ago may not fit your taste now.

If your bench looks old or worn out, and you want to update your room, a new bench is a great choice.

A fresh style can make your home feel new again.


13. The Bench Makes Noise

Sometimes benches creak, squeak, or make other noises when you sit or open them.

This can be annoying or a sign of loose parts.

If tightening screws or adding oil does not stop the noise, it may be time to replace the bench.


14. You Have Safety Concerns

Safety is very important. If your bench has sharp edges, splinters, or broken parts, it can cause injuries.

Also, if the bench is not stable or wobbles, it can be unsafe.

Always check your bench for safety. If you find risks, replace it immediately.


15. It No Longer Meets Your Lifestyle

Your lifestyle may change. For example, you may have children, pets, or move to a smaller home.

If your current bench does not fit your new lifestyle or needs, consider replacing it.

A bench that fits your life makes your home more comfortable.


How to Prepare for Replacement

When you decide to replace your storage bench, think about:

  • Where you will put the new bench

  • What size and style you want

  • What you want to store inside it

  • How often you will use it

Take measurements of your space before buying a new bench.


How to Dispose of the Old Bench

Once you replace your bench, you need to get rid of the old one.

Here are some ideas:

  • Donate it if it is still usable

  • Sell it if it is in good condition

  • Recycle parts like wood or metal

  • Arrange for a trash pickup for bulky items

Always try to recycle or donate first. This helps reduce waste.


Final Thoughts

A storage bench is a helpful piece of furniture. But like all things, it has a life cycle. Knowing when to replace it can save you from discomfort or problems.

Replace your bench if it is broken, unsafe, or too small. Also consider replacing it if it no longer fits your style or needs.

Taking care of your storage bench can make it last longer. But when it is time, replacing it is the best choice.

A new storage bench can give you comfort, style, and better storage. It can make your home more organized and beautiful.

Remember to choose the right size, material, and style for your needs. This way, your new bench will serve you well for many years.